Substack alternative · Comparison

A Substack alternative that keeps your list and your revenue

Substack made publishing email easy — and took 10% of everything you earned from paid subscriptions. LetterFlight is a different shape of tool: newsletter hosting where the audience you build belongs to you, sent from fully authenticated, DKIM-signed infrastructure, with no cut taken from your work.

No credit card · Double opt-in on every list · One-click unsubscribe in every email

Free plans, side by side

All figures below are taken from each platform's public pricing pages in November 2026 — check the vendor pages for the current state of play.

PlatformFree planCut on paid subscriptionsWhat it is
Substack Free to publish 10% + payment processing Publication platform with its own discovery network
Buttondown 100 subscribers 0% — charges a subscription instead Developer-focused newsletter tool
Mailchimp Free tier discontinued (14-day trial; paid from $13/month) 0% — charges a subscription instead Full marketing platform (email is one channel of many)
Kit 10,000 subscribers (one publication) 0% — charges a subscription instead Creator-economy email tool
LetterFlight 500 subscribers 0% — your revenue stays yours Newsletter hosting built around deliverability

Caps and cuts change; vendors revise pricing often. Kit's free tier covers a single publication. The honest takeaway: pick the shape of tool you need first, then compare caps.

Weighing Buttondown, Mailchimp or MailerLite too? We keep dedicated pages for those: the Buttondown alternative (their free plan stops at 100 subscribers, ours doesn't stop until 500), the Mailchimp comparison (a marketing suite vs a newsletter tool — and their permanent free tier is now a 14-day trial) and the MailerLite alternative (their free tier holds 1,000 subscribers; LetterFlight Pro is $9/month for 3,000).

Switch in 3 steps

Most migrations are done the same afternoon you export. The full walk-through lives on our migration guide.

1Export from Substack

In Substack: Dashboard → Subscribers → Export your email list. The CSV only contains current subscribers — there's no opt-out list to bring over, because Substack's export doesn't include people who've left.

2Import into LetterFlight

In your LetterFlight dashboard, use Migrate from another platform: subscribers land as confirmed — no confirmation emails, no re-permissioning people who've already said yes. Up to 5,000 rows per migration, and statuses we don't recognize are held as unconfirmed rather than guessed.

3Point your domain at us

Bring your own domain: add the 3 DNS records (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) and hit Verify. If your domain carries any old newsletter platform's SPF record, delete that one first — two SPF records are a hard failure (SPF permerror) and nothing sends. Then ramp, don't blast: new sender + fresh list means watch Google Postmaster Tools, keep complaints under 0.1% and bounces under 2%, send your most active subscribers first, and build volume over 1–2 weeks.

When Substack is the right choice

Substack deserves the credit it gets. If you're starting from zero audience and want discovery — new readers finding you inside Substack's network — it is genuinely useful, and the 10% cut only applies when you actually earn money. Writers who never charge subscribers pay nothing.

The trade is ownership. On Substack your list lives inside their platform, your archive lives on their domain, and paid revenue passes through their 10%. For many writers that's a fair price for the network effect.

When a hosted tool fits better

If you already have an audience — or you're building one deliberately under your own brand — the calculus changes. You want paid-subscription revenue (present or future) to stay 100% yours. And you want deliverability handled as infrastructure: enforced double opt-in, one-click unsubscribe and DKIM-signed email by default. (Want to send under your own domain? Self-serve: add your domain, add 3 DNS records, verify, done.)

That's the gap LetterFlight fills. Three things we treat as defaults rather than upsells:

Authenticated sending by default

Every email is DKIM-signed from our fully authenticated sending domain (SPF, DKIM and DMARC all in place). Prefer your own domain? Self-serve: add your domain, add 3 DNS records, verify, and your mail goes out DKIM-signed from your domain.

Zero platform cut

Free up to 500 subscribers, and we never take a percentage of what you earn from your writing. Our business model is a subscription, not your revenue.

Deliverability is the product

Forced double opt-in, RFC-compliant one-click unsubscribe in every email, automatic bounce cleaning. Defaults you can't switch off — on purpose.

Questions people ask when leaving Substack

How is LetterFlight different from Substack?

Substack is a publication platform: it hosts your archive, runs its own recommendation network and takes 10% of paid revenue. LetterFlight is hosting infrastructure: your newsletter is sent from authenticated, DKIM-signed infrastructure, your subscriber list is yours to export as CSV any time, and we charge a subscription (the free tier is free) instead of a revenue share. Think "email hosting with deliverability built in", not "publishing network".

Do you take a cut of my paid subscriptions?

No. LetterFlight never takes a percentage of your revenue on any plan. If you monetize your newsletter — through paid tiers, sponsorships or anything else — every cent of it stays with you.

Can I migrate my existing Substack list?

Yes. Export your subscriber CSV from Substack and bring it into LetterFlight with Migrate from another platform in your dashboard: subscribers land as confirmed — no confirmation emails, no re-permissioning people who've already said yes. One note: Substack's export only contains current subscribers, so there's no separate opt-out list to carry over — anyone who unsubscribed is already gone from the file.

Why is double opt-in forced? Substack doesn't do that.

Because deliverability dies without it. Buying lists or importing unconfirmed addresses is the fastest route to spam-folder purgatory — mailbox providers judge your whole domain by the actions of your least-engaged subscribers. Confirming every address is the single highest-leverage deliverability practice, so we made it impossible to skip.

What does the free plan include?

Up to 500 subscribers with no platform cut: forced double opt-in, DKIM-signed email from our authenticated sending domain (SPF, DKIM and DMARC in place), plain-text friendly templates, automatic hard-bounce cleaning and one-click unsubscribe headers in every email. No credit card to start.